← Back to Crime
Crime By Michael A.G. · Nov 19, 2026

South Carolina Parole Board Denies Release for Susan Smith, Convicted Killer of Two Children

Convicted child murderer Susan Smith was denied parole by the South Carolina Board of Paroles and Pardons during a hearing held in Columbia on November 19, 2026. The board's decision means that Smith will remain incarcerated for at least another two years following her initial conviction in 1994.

Smith, now 55 years old, has been serving time since she was found guilty of drowning her two young sons—Michael, aged three, and Alex, who was just 14 months old—in a car that she submerged in John D. Long Lake. The case shocked the nation when Smith initially claimed that a Black man had stolen her vehicle along with her children after a carjacking incident.

After nine days of extensive media coverage and search efforts, Smith confessed to fabricating the story and admitted to drowning her sons herself. She has since been incarcerated for 32 years, facing intense public scrutiny and opposition from those who believe she should remain behind bars indefinitely.

During Thursday's hearing, Smith appeared via video link and expressed remorse for her actions. "I know that what I did was horrible," she said, addressing the parole board directly. "Michael and Alex were innocent children who didn't deserve to die. My lowest moment came when I let that car go into the lake."

The case continues to generate significant public interest, with over 10,845 individuals submitting petitions opposing Smith's release. Among those advocating for her continued incarceration is Tommy Pope, the former solicitor who prosecuted Smith and now serves as speaker pro tempore of the South Carolina House of Representatives.

Pope argued that allowing Smith to be released would not only fail to address justice but also potentially allow her to exploit her crimes through media appearances. "If you remember back then, she relished the media attention," Pope reminded the board. "And I submit nothing's changed in that regard."

In contrast, Smith’s legal team presented evidence suggesting that her mental health had improved over time. Dr. Jessica Hill, a forensic psychiatrist hired by Smith's attorney, testified that Smith had been diagnosed with borderline personality disorder following traumatic experiences earlier in life. However, she argued that Smith had matured beyond this diagnosis and was now capable of reintegrating into society responsibly.

Despite the conflicting testimonies and public sentiment, the parole board unanimously decided to deny Smith’s request for release. This decision underscores the ongoing debate over rehabilitation versus retribution in high-profile criminal cases and highlights the enduring impact of such tragic events on communities and families involved.

The case of Susan Smith continues to captivate public attention nearly three decades after her crime, reflecting broader societal discussions about forgiveness, redemption, and the consequences of violent acts.

← Back to Crime